The Most Trusted Website For Attorney Reviews – Yelp!

Yelp 3It’s true.  Yelp is the most trusted website for attorney reviews. And if you are not getting good reviews on Yelp you better start having a plan in place to do so.

I love to give examples taken from real life.  While this particular story isn’t about lawyers on Yelp it is about the influence of crowd-sourced review sites.

After over a year of planning, I took a cruise this past April. (Unfortunately, our cruise was interrupted due to the sudden death of a close family member.) However, throughout the whole planning phase from travel agent, to airline, to cruise ship, to excursions, I religiously consulted Trip Advisor. I read all reviews.  It didn’t matter what the airline, cruise or excursions advertised, I made my final decisions based upon crowd-sourced reviews from those who had actually gone through the experience I was interested in.  When I had questions, I joined a Facebook Group designed to share information, answer questions and get guidance.  No details were too small and as a result, I was very pleased with all the final decisions.

Now, here is the really interesting part.  Before our trip was interrupted, we were able to do two wonderful excursions; snorkeling and swimming with the stingrays.  At the end of each excursion, our guides handed us business cards with information on how to write a review on Trip Advisor.  Each told us that their livelihoods depended upon a positive review (providing we liked the excursion) and rather enthusiastically encouraged us to use the ship’s wifi and participate in writing a 5 – star review of our experience, to even post pictures if we had them.  It was so important to them that they didn’t mind being rather heavy-handed when asking us to do so.  But the message was clear – they understood how critical a positive review on these crowd-sourced review sites was and they weren’t ashamed to work for a good review and ask for a good review.  They didn’t take their jobs lightly or give short shrift to the power of social media.

Then just last week I was looking for a dog trainer.  I found an interesting website, checked out the reviews and called.  When the prospective trainer talked with me on the phone the first thing he asked was, ‘How did you hear of me?’.  I told him I found his website and there were some good testimonials. He said, ‘Did you see my Yelp reviews?  I’ve got some really good reviews on Yelp.”

Lawyers, on the other hand, the ones who are starting to wake up to the fact that crowd-sourced reviews sites are the ‘new’ word-of-mouth, are going to sites advertised specifically for lawyers.  Shouldn’t they first be going to sites where the consumers are actually congregating and seeking out advice? They can always work the other sites later.

That brings us back to Yelp. Why aren’t more lawyers actively going to Yelp and participating?

“Yelp is the most commonly used site to search for attorney reviews online—58 percent of respondents in our sample said it was the first place they turn. It’s also the website that 61 percent of users view as the most trustworthy,” says Chantelle Wallace, Managing Editor of Software Advice.

This is dramatic news considering that most consumers go online to look for an attorney. In fact, the new survey finds that 83% of consumers use online review sites as the first step in searching for an attorney. Furthermore:

“…more consumers are reading reviews as part of their pre-purchase research before selecting a local business to use.

However, it also shows that they are forming opinions faster and needing to read fewer reviews before they trust (or don’t trust) a local business. This puts increased emphasis on local businesses to manage their online reputation closely and ensure that any negative reviews are dealt with in a swift and positive way.

As for the big name legal review sites, they have a very small market share for lawyer review searches compared to Yelp’s 58% lawyer review searches…. and this number is growing.

And now:

A lawyer may offer clients a $50 credit on their legal bills to provide voluntary, honest and independently generated reviews of the lawyer’s services on websites such as Avvo that allow such evaluations, the New York state bar’s ethics committee declared March 25.

At the end of the day, even the legal profession, known for being far behind the learning curve when it comes to the importance of marketing, is conceding there is value in social media ‘word-of-mouth’.  This is a type of ‘social selling -  when (salespeople) use social media to interact directly with their prospects. (Salespeople) will provide value by answering prospect questions and offering thoughtful content until the prospect is ready to buy. Using a review, while not direct to one particular prospect, falls into this category, in my opinion. What does strike me odd is that this is dangerously close to a ‘gift’ for generating business, something which has been frowned upon since long before I became a lawyer.  But the opinion referenced does address this issue and they’ve managed to skirt it quite nicely and, for once, in the lawyers’ favor.

I would like you to consider one other thing before you read the post I’m going to refer you to below. Word of mouth marketing is the brass ring which every attorney aspires to grab.  Traditionally, word of mouth was from one person’s mouth to one person’s ear.  Today’s word of mouth is social media – one person’s keyboard to tens of thousands of eyes.  Review sites are word of mouth and you should take review sites such as Yelp as seriously as the guides for my excursions did.  They were clear.  Their livelihood depended upon a positive review from satisfied customers. Yours will, too.

Here is a great guest post on the Referral Power of Positive Reviews on Yelp written by a lawyer who uses Yelp successfully.

Are you using crowd-sourced review sites?  If so, please share your experience with us.

This entry was posted in Marketing, Social Media and tagged Legal Marketing, Yelp. Bookmark the permalink.

Enjoy our blog posts with lunch! Enter your email address and we'll send you an email each time a new blog post is published.

Want your free copy of Business Call is Back and Attorney Guide to Virtual Receptionists? Subscribe by email below and you will be able to download them immediately.

6 comments on “The Most Trusted Website For Attorney Reviews – Yelp!

  • This is very important and I think this article is right on point. One thing to consider though is that you often need to make sure that the client not only reviews you on Yelp but has additional reviews elsewhere on Yelp because if they just write one review for your office and it is a glowing 5 star review they might not end up with that review posted publicly. Yelp has been quite loudly challenged for their choice to manipulate reviews and so far courts have upheld this as perfectly OK.

    For that reason I tend to ask clients to write reviews on Google Plus rather than Yelp. Though, while they won’t remove client’s reviews for being their only review they also don’t do much to police fake reviews and remove those.

  • I’ve had similar problems to Paul. The couple of times I asked clients for Yelp reviews, the clients had to create profiles, and my firm was their only review…. so Yelp doesn’t show them because they are not ‘recommended’ reviews. Now I just ask clients to leave Google reviews.

  • Interesting. I’ll start asking clients for reviews on Yelp! And in light of the previous comment, maybe I’ll ask them if they’ve written other reviews on Yelp…
    Anyone know of any website terms of service preventing a client from posting the same review at multiple sites? Or ethical prohibition, or SEO penalty, for that?

    • Matt, the opinion referenced in the post makes the parameters fairly clear. It also doesn’t limit the number of reviews or review sites. This may be heresy but I wouldn’t worry about SEO penalties. This misses the point. If it is an honest review and done by a client and it’s placed on a credible review site and the client wants to post it on more than one credible review site, let them do it without thought to SEO penalties. Let things happen organically within the parameters mentioned but also keep in mind, this is a New York opinion and does not necessarily represent the opinion of your jurisdiction if you are not practicing in New York.

  • This is great information. A fellow coach, who had provided services, asked me if I would review her on Yelp. Since I am with the baby boomer generation, I would not have considered the importance of this. I found this very helpful and shared on my Linkedin and Twitter feeds. Thanks!

  • It’s a shame that Yelp reviews are considered so trustworthy when Yelp is such a crooked company. But you know how it goes – play by their rules or die.

Comments are closed automatically 60 days after the post is published.