The 8 Deadly Wastes in a Law Office: What AI Fixes and What It Adds
- For a law firm, Lean defines value as whatever the client says it is; anything the client wouldn't pay for is waste.
- AI cuts waiting, re-keying and routine clerical rework, especially on the business side of the practice.
- AI adds waste too: drafts nobody asked for, unverified output, and a new kind of rework spent checking the machine.
Lean thinking came out of Toyota's factories, and it teaches you to see eight kinds of waste. Solo Practice University's Lean Six Sigma for Solos course, recorded for SPU in 2013–15, showed lawyers where those wastes hide in a law office. A decade later, AI can remove some of them in seconds. It can also produce new waste faster than any copier ever did. Here's how to tell which is which.
Value first, then waste
The course started with value, not efficiency, and its definition is blunt. In the words of instructors Nora Riva Bergman and Liz Lamar:
"Value is defined by the customer, your client. And anything that's not value to your client is waste."
Lean gives value three tests, and an activity has to pass all three. The client is willing to pay for it. It changes the client's situation: they become a plaintiff, or they now know something about their contract they didn't know before. And it's done right the first time. On that last test, the course didn't leave room for "close enough":
"The activity must be done right the first time every time."
Retyping a pleading because you caught a typo before filing fails the third test. So does any work the client didn't need. The instructors admitted all of this sounds like common sense, and then explained why it still matters: "the problem with common sense is that it is not common action."
Keep those three tests in mind. They're the fastest way to judge any AI tool you're thinking of adding to the practice.
The eight wastes, in plain terms
Taiichi Ohno, the engineer behind the Toyota Production System, originally identified seven wastes. An eighth, non-utilized talent, was added later as lean spread beyond the factory floor (see the Lean Enterprise Institute and The Lean Way). The course taught all eight with the acronym DOWNTIME, because that's what they create in your office: defects, overproduction, waiting, non-utilized talent, transportation, inventory, motion and extra processing.
The law-office versions are familiar. Defects are clerical errors in leases and pleadings, plus the time spent fixing them. Waiting is the draft your assistant turned in on deadline that then sat in your inbox for a week. Inventory is the pile of files on your desk. And the course had a pointed answer to where the bottleneck in a small firm usually sits: "guess who the bottleneck usually is, it's you."
One adjustment the course made for law firms: a factory can do a "waste walk" and see piles of parts on the floor. Most law-office waste is invisible, so the course suggested a waste talk instead, sitting down with your staff (or just yourself) and naming where the time goes.
DOWNTIME: the 8 wastes and AI
Cuts AI tends to reduce it Adds AI can create more Both depends on how you use it
Where AI cuts waste
Waiting. The course called waiting "a productivity killer and a morale killer." Its examples included chasing clients for documents and slow email replies in both directions. AI helps with the routine end of this: a first draft of a standard letter in minutes instead of a day in the queue, and reminders that go out to clients without anyone remembering to send them. A well-built client intake form paired with automated follow-up removes a lot of nagging. What AI can't fix is the draft that waits on you. If you're the bottleneck, a faster first draft just makes the pile on your desk grow faster.
Transportation and extra processing. The course flagged data "being copied or moved from one program to another," and the same data kept in several systems. That's re-keying a new client's details from an email into a conflicts check, then a calendar, then an engagement letter. Pulling structured information out of a form or an email and dropping it where it belongs is exactly the kind of chore AI does well.
Clerical defects on routine documents. The course's worksheet example was frequent redrafting of leases because of corrections and missing elements, and the fix was a checklist. A checklist is also a good prompt. Asking an AI tool to compare your draft against your own checklist for missing clauses, wrong names or inconsistent dates catches the clerical errors the course had in mind. You still read the result.
Non-utilized talent. This is where the course and the AI era line up best. The instructors told solos to put one question on a sticky note:
"Is what I'm doing right now the highest and best use of my time?"
When they taught the course, the answer for most solos was to get help with delegating, whether a virtual or in-office assistant. Today some of that help is software. John O'Connor, founder of Associate and SPU's Professor of AI Fluency, draws the line in the same place the course did:
"Use AI to delegate everything around the practice, the business side."
Scheduling, intake admin, billing follow-up, marketing operations and documents about the practice are where AI belongs first. That's the business side of a solo practice that law school never taught, and it's where most of the eight wastes live.
Where AI adds waste
Overproduction. The course defined it as "anything that is created faster than needed, sooner than needed…" or in greater quantity than needed. One of its law-firm examples was doing more research than the client required. When a memo costs nothing to generate, you can produce five versions, three alternative arguments and a twenty-page research summary for a client who wanted a yes or no. None of it passes the first value test. Somebody still has to read it, and that somebody is you.
Defects from unverified output. This is the expensive one. In 2023, a federal judge in Manhattan fined two lawyers and their firm $5,000 in Mata v. Avianca after they filed a brief citing cases ChatGPT had made up (ABA Journal, LawNext). The judge said there was nothing "inherently improper" about using AI, but that "existing rules impose a gatekeeping role on attorneys to ensure the accuracy of their filings." O'Connor names the habit behind cases like that:
"The lethal AI habit for lawyers is cognitive surrender of work product."
A clerical typo costs you a reprint. A fabricated citation costs you credibility with the court. Under the course's definition, both are defects, but AI makes the second kind possible at scale. ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 2024) lists the duties in play when lawyers use generative AI, among them the duties "to supervise their employees and agents, to advance only meritorious claims and contentions, to ensure candor toward the tribunal." For more on the ethics side, see our guest lecture on the ethics of using AI, and check your own jurisdiction's rules.
A new kind of rework. Checking AI output is real work. If every AI draft of a motion needs a line-by-line rewrite, you haven't removed rework, you've moved it. It also fails the "right the first time" test by design. That's fine for a routine letter where the check takes two minutes. It's a bad trade for work where the review takes longer than writing it yourself would have.
Motion, transportation and inventory, again. Pasting text from a chat window into Word, re-prompting, and saving drafts to a folder you'll "review later" are the same wastes the course described, in new clothes. The course's warning applies: "Wasted motion can create the sense that people are busy, but being busy doesn't mean you're adding value." Prompting, re-prompting and pasting can feel productive. Unreviewed drafts are inventory, and inventory, the course said, covers up other problems.
There's a cost to attention too. O'Connor's advice is to "use AI sparingly where it is corrosive to focus and attention span." The core legal thinking is the work clients pay for. It's not the place to save time.
Before you hand a task to AI
- Would the client pay for this?If not, cut it rather than automate it.
- Does it change the client's situation?Five extra versions of a memo don't.
- Who checks it before it goes out?Right the first time still means you.
- Is it business side or work product?Delegate the first. Guard your thinking on the second.
Run a waste talk before you buy a tool
The practical move is the one the course assigned: list where waste shows up in your firm, propose a fix for each, and decide how you'll measure it. The instructors asked, "How will you know in your law firm if you've been successful in your project?" A measure might be no more redrafting for clerical errors, or client documents in hand within a week.
Only then ask which fixes involve AI. Most of the good answers will be on the business side: intake, scheduling, billing, the law office email that buries everything else. Start with the front door. If your website's contact form sends inquiries into an inbox nobody checks until Thursday, that's waiting waste before the client has even hired you. SPU offers a free law firm website review if you want a second pair of eyes on it.
Fixing waste first also keeps you from automating a bad process. AI applied to a messy workflow produces a faster messy workflow. Lawyers have always been knowledge workers, and the knowledge is the value. Everything around it is fair game. For more on tools and practice systems, browse our technology coverage.
Go deeper: Before You Build
This post covers a slice of the course's lessons on value and waste. The adapted course is live in the SPU community as Before You Build: Mapping Your Practice for AI. It also covers continuous improvement with Kaizen and DMAIC, 5S for your desk, files and email, process mapping, knowledge management, and worksheets, including the waste talk checklist. It's included with SPU membership, along with the community, monthly strategy sessions and the course library.
Get one practical lesson for your firm every week.
Free, from practicing lawyers. Every issue includes a lesson from the archive. Unsubscribe anytime.
The SPU Team writes and edits Solo Practice University's articles. Susan Cartier Liebel founded SPU in 2009 to teach lawyers the practical side of building a practice, the part law school leaves out, with courses taught by practicing lawyers. Today SPU is a community for solo and small-firm lawyers, with an AI Fluency program for firms putting AI to work. Nothing here is legal advice: check your own jurisdiction's rules.
About Solo Practice University →