Get your firm's free AI report card
BLOG POST · SOLO & SMALL FIRM PRACTICE

Legal Blogging When AI Can Write a Post in Seconds

TL;DR
  • Generic legal content is now free and worthless, so your blog has to show judgment and opinion only you can supply.
  • Pick one audience, write to those readers only, and publish on a schedule you can keep, even once a week.
  • Use AI for scaffolding like drafts and headings, but keep the opinions and war stories yours and check every fact.

Any lawyer can now get a competent-sounding 800-word post on "What to do after a car accident" out of a chatbot before the coffee cools. So can every other lawyer in town. When generic content costs nothing, generic content is worth nothing. That changes what a legal blog is for, and it sends us back to one of the biggest courses in the Solo Practice University archive.

SPU's Legal Blogging course ran from 2007 to 2010: 85 lessons on why a solo should blog, how to do it, and how not to burn out doing it. A lot of it is pure period piece. There are lessons on Google Reader, trackbacks, the WordPress "kitchen sink" button and a 30-day Twitter series. But the core ideas were never about the tools, and they read better now than they did then.

A blog was never a publishing business

The course opened with a claim that sounds obvious today and wasn't in 2008: a blog is not a brochure. It called a blog a "Conversation, Relationship and Meeting place," and built its method on four verbs borrowed from early blog-marketing writers: find the conversations in your niche, listen to them, engage in them, and empower readers to tell their own stories. The point of all four was relationships, not traffic.

What the course said a blog is

Not a brochure.

Conversation
Relationship
Meeting place

The method, in four verbs: Find Listen Engage Empower

From SPU's Legal Blogging course (2007 to 2010), which borrowed the four verbs from early blog-marketing writers. The point of all four: relationships, not traffic.

That framing matters more now, because the other model of legal content (pump out pages, rank, collect visits) is exactly the one AI has flattened. John O'Connor, founder of Associate and SPU's Professor of AI Fluency, puts it bluntly:

"It's no longer about law firms as publishers, as if they were trying to monetize page views."

SPU's own archive has been arguing about this for years. Our writers asked whether blogging was dead in 2012, and again in 2014 whether lawyers were just dying from blogging under the time it takes. The answer then was that the effort pays when the writing is yours. AI hasn't changed that answer. It has raised the stakes on it.

Write for a reader, not a search engine

One of the course's sharpest lessons was a complaint about bloggers obsessed with stats and page rank. Its fix was simple:

"Folks, Google doesn't control whether your blog will be successful or not. You do... Write to and for your reader. Your ideal reader."

The course went further on who that reader is. In a 2009 lesson on whether to blog for clients or peers, it argued that writing for other lawyers can work because it shows off real expertise, and expertise is what a client in trouble is shopping for. Its final lesson came back to one rule: choose an audience before you start, and write to those people only. "Consistency is key." Another SPU writer worked through the same question in 2013, asking whether lawyers' blogs are for lawyers or clients, and found the readership often skews to lawyers whatever the author intends.

Google's current guidance says much the same thing in its own terms. Its documentation on creating helpful, people-first content asks: "Does your content clearly demonstrate first-hand expertise and a depth of knowledge?" It also asks whether content is made for people rather than to game rankings. In December 2022 Google added "experience" to its E-A-T quality concept, making it E-E-A-T, and described experience as content produced by someone with first-hand, life experience of the topic.

What Google says about AI-written content

Google doesn't ban AI content. In February 2023 guidance it said that "not all use of automation, including AI generation, is spam," and that using AI "doesn't give content any special gains." What it does penalize is volume for its own sake. In March 2024 Google announced a "scaled content abuse" policy covering content produced at scale to boost rankings, "whether automation, humans or a combination are involved." Its spam policies now list "using generative AI tools or other similar tools to generate many pages without adding value for users" as an example.

Read together, the message for a solo is plain. AI drafting isn't the risk. Publishing the same answer everyone else's chatbot gives is.

Opinion is the part AI can't fake for you

The course's last lesson, titled "If You Forget Everything Else You Ever Learned About Blogging, Remember This," gave lawyers permission most of them still don't take:

"It's okay to have personal opinions, and it's okay to talk about issues from an opinionated standpoint rather than a strictly legal one."

It added a line every lawyer-writer should tape to the monitor: "when was the last time you enjoyed reading a legal brief?" A companion lesson made the same case on style. "The whole point of a blog is to communicate something about which you're an expert in simple, everyday, person-to-person terms," it said, then told readers to strip the legalese and chop their paragraphs short.

Opinion and first-hand experience are exactly what a general-purpose model doesn't have about your practice. It hasn't sat with your clients, watched your local judges, or lost the motion you now warn people about. O'Connor sees that as the whole game:

"Opinionated, agentic process informed by deep subject matter expertise will be a feature of the AI future."

And on what clients actually buy once AI drafts and researches: "They hire that lawyer's AI, plus judgment, plus signoff." A blog is where a prospective client sees that judgment before they hire it. If the post could have been written by anyone's chatbot, it shows them nothing.

The course profiled a Canadian solo who started a niche blog in 2007, at a time when no other lawyer in the country was blogging in that area. The lawyer described the problem the blog solved:

"I had all this knowledge in my head, but no one really knew that I knew what I knew. I needed a platform."

That is still the job. AI can help get the knowledge onto the page faster. It can't supply the knowledge. If you worry you don't know enough yet, SPU has an older piece on blogging when you don't feel like an expert.

The ghostwriter question, again

In April 2009 the course posted a lesson with no answer, only a question: should a legal blogger use a ghostwriter? It asked readers to weigh in, and called it "a hot topic right now and quite frankly, an important one to consider."

Swap "ghostwriter" for "AI" and the question is back, with more force. A practical way to split the work:

  • Use AI for the scaffolding. Turning your dictated notes into a first draft, suggesting headings, tightening long paragraphs, checking a post against your outline, drafting the meta description.
  • Keep the substance yours. The opinion, the war story (anonymized), the local detail, the "here's what I'd actually do." Those are what make a post worth reading and worth ranking.
  • Check every fact and citation yourself. A blog post is lawyer advertising and a public statement under your name. Your bar's advertising rules, and your own judgment about what you sign, still apply. SPU's guest lecture on the ethics of using AI in practice is a good start; check your own jurisdiction's rules.

Google's helpful-content documentation also asks whether the use of automation is "self-evident to visitors through disclosures or in other ways," and suggests explaining how AI was used where readers might reasonably ask. Whether and how to disclose is your call under your jurisdiction's rules, but a byline from a real lawyer who stands behind the post is the baseline.

Consistency beats volume

The course started out preaching "blog early, blog often" and three posts a week. By the end it had changed its mind, and the final lesson warned about burnout instead:

"It's perfectly fine to blog only once a week – but be sure you can stick to that schedule."

That evolution is the right one for the AI era. Volume is now free and therefore worthless. A steady rhythm of posts that answer your clients' real questions, in your voice, with your opinions, is the part competitors can't copy by prompting harder. Another SPU writer made a related point about website copy: lawyers win when they talk about the problems they solve, not their credentials.

Volume vs. voice

VolumeGeneric AI contentThe same answer everyone else's chatbot givesCould have been written by anyone's chatbotFree, and therefore worthless
VoiceExperience-led postsYour opinion, war story and local detailYour clients' real questions, on a steady rhythmCan't be copied by prompting harder
AI drafting isn't the risk. Publishing the same answer everyone else's chatbot gives is.

The course also covered a lot we haven't touched here: choosing a blog name, the pages every business blog needs, handling negative comments, finding post ideas at different times of the workday, and whether you need to be a blogger at all. If you want more from the archive, browse SPU's marketing posts.

Writing well is only half the problem. The other half is whether anyone finds it when Google or a chatbot answers the question first. That's the subject of our companion piece, Getting Found When AI Answers the Question.

Write with other solos

The hardest part of blogging was never the software. It was keeping going. SPU membership gets you the community, monthly strategy sessions and the course library, so you're not building your practice, or your voice, alone.

THE WEEKLY SPU BRIEF

Get one practical lesson for your firm every week.

Free, from practicing lawyers. Every issue includes a lesson from the archive. Unsubscribe anytime.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
The SPU Team

The SPU Team writes and edits Solo Practice University's articles. Susan Cartier Liebel founded SPU in 2009 to teach lawyers the practical side of building a practice, the part law school leaves out, with courses taught by practicing lawyers. Today SPU is a community for solo and small-firm lawyers, with an AI Fluency program for firms putting AI to work. Nothing here is legal advice: check your own jurisdiction's rules.

About Solo Practice University →