Get your firm's free AI report card
BLOG POST · SOLO & SMALL FIRM PRACTICE

How to Set a Fixed Price for Legal Work: Jay Shepherd's 14 Steps

TL;DR
  • You sell things, not time, so set a fixed price from the client, the matter and the market, never from hours.
  • Work through the 14 steps, from analyzing the client and the stakes to choosing one price or phases, then say it.
  • AI is cutting legal work's hours; if the hours shrink and the value doesn't, hourly pricing leaves money on the table.

"How do you set your prices?" is the first question every lawyer asks when they hear a firm doesn't bill by the hour. Jay Shepherd, who ran a Boston employment firm on fixed prices with no timesheets, answered it in his Solo Practice University course with a 14-step list. Here it is, in his words where we can quote him.

The 14 steps at a glance

13 factors, then one price

Steps 1 · 10 · 11Know the clientWho they are, future work, past work
Steps 2 · 3 · 5Know the matterImportance, urgency, stakes
Steps 4 · 8 · 9Know the marketCompetitors, your past prices, light or heavy
Steps 6 · 7Know your edgeHow replaceable you are, how much expertise matters
Steps 12–14DecideWant it? One price or phases? Say the price.
The steps are the course's; the grouping is ours. The full list, in order, is below.

Fixed pricing matters more now that AI is cutting the time legal work takes, especially transactional work. If the hours shrink and the value doesn't, pricing by the hour leaves money on the table. (We covered why in AI Makes You Faster. The Billable Hour Makes That a Pay Cut.)

First: you sell things, not time

Before the list, Jay set one ground rule. Stop measuring work in hours, even privately.

"You don't sell time, you sell things... Your client doesn't care how many hours something takes."

His comparison: nobody asks a surgeon how long a gallbladder operation will take, or pays for it by the hour. And he didn't accept that litigation was the exception. His practice was mostly employment litigation, and his view was simple: "if you can price litigation you can price anything."

Jay's 14 steps to setting a price

  1. Analyze the client. Is this a sophisticated buyer of legal services, like a company with a legal department, or a family business that has never been sued? What drives them, and what worries them?
  2. Assess the importance of the matter. A claim against a short-term employee and a harassment claim against the CEO are not the same matter, and the price should reflect it. Jay called this price discrimination in the economist's sense, not price gouging.
  3. Assess the urgency. Dropping everything for a hearing tomorrow commands a premium, and clients expect to pay one.
  4. Know what competitors charge, but don't copy them. "Pay attention to what the market is, but don't automatically mimic whatever your other firms are doing. That's not pricing, that's just following along."
  5. Weigh the stakes. What do the possible outcomes mean to this client, objectively and subjectively?
  6. Ask how hard you'd be to replace. If any lawyer could do it from a template, there's little premium. If it's your niche, charge for that.
  7. Ask how much your expertise changes the outcome. Some matters turn on who handles them. Some don't, whether because anyone could win them or because nobody could.
  8. Look at what you've charged for similar work. It's a waypoint, not a rule.
  9. Ask whether those past prices were light or heavy. Not "did we lose money," but "was the work worth more, or less, to the client than we charged?"
  10. Consider future work from this client. You're pricing a relationship, not just a matter. But be careful: a low price to win more work can leave you stuck at that price.
  11. Consider past work from this client. Loyal clients can earn a better price.
  12. Decide how much you want the work. If you're ambivalent, that's a signal to charge more. You may find you're less ambivalent once the price is right.
  13. Decide between one price and phases. Jay found himself moving toward fewer, larger price points, comparing itemized legal fees to airline add-on fees: clients just want to hear "give me a price."
  14. Say the price. The first 13 are factors. The last step is telling the client: "I say, this is our price."

Value pricing isn't discount pricing

Jay worried that "value pricing" sounds like "cheap." He argued the opposite: the certainty of a fixed price is worth something, and clients pay for it.

"Value pricing can be premium pricing."

His analogy was the mortgage market: a fixed-rate mortgage costs more than an adjustable one because the borrower is paying for certainty. A fixed legal fee works the same way. You can still save clients money, because hourly billing builds in so much waste, but that doesn't mean you have to charge less.

The mortgage analogy

Certainty is worth paying for

MortgageFixed rateCosts more than adjustable. The borrower pays for certainty.
Legal feeFixed priceWorks the same way. Clients pay for certainty.
The analogy is from the course: "Value pricing can be premium pricing."

Don't keep a secret timesheet

The most common mistake Jay saw was firms quoting fixed prices while still tracking time "to see if they're losing money." His verdict: then "you're just timekeeping and you're covering it up with a price." You'll second-guess every price and give up. If you're nervous, run a pilot on certain kinds of matters, but commit to it. His firm tracked its work so it could tell clients what was happening, but never its time.

Next, read how Jay wrote fixed-price agreements: scope, phases and change orders. Fee rules vary by jurisdiction, so check your own before you change how you charge. Once your prices are set, look at how your website talks about fees, since that is often a client's first impression of them. SPU offers a free website review for law firms.

Watch the full course

The course covers all 14 steps on video, along with whether to look at old bills, why not to reverse engineer hourly rates, and how to price litigation, transactional and advice work. Fixing Your Fees, Fixing Your Practice is in the SPU community and included with SPU membership. Finish with the practice exercise: price one of your own services and get feedback from other members.

THE WEEKLY SPU BRIEF

Get one practical lesson for your firm every week.

Free, from practicing lawyers. Every issue includes a lesson from the archive. Unsubscribe anytime.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
The SPU Team

The SPU Team writes and edits Solo Practice University's articles. Susan Cartier Liebel founded SPU in 2009 to teach lawyers the practical side of building a practice, the part law school leaves out, with courses taught by practicing lawyers. Today SPU is a community for solo and small-firm lawyers, with an AI Fluency program for firms putting AI to work. Nothing here is legal advice: check your own jurisdiction's rules.

About Solo Practice University →