Get your firm's free AI report card
BLOG POST · SOLO & SMALL FIRM PRACTICE

Fixed-Price Agreements That Hold Up: Scope, Phases and Change Orders

TL;DR
  • Put the price and the scope in writing, in plain language, so the fixed price survives the actual matter.
  • Price in a few large phases, not line items, and save change orders for new work, not things you should have anticipated.
  • If AI makes your transactional work faster, a fixed-price agreement turns that speed into margin instead of a smaller bill.

Setting a fixed price is half the job. The other half is writing it down so the price survives contact with the actual matter. Jay Shepherd, who ran his Boston employment firm without hourly billing, spent a full module of his Solo Practice University course on fixed-price agreements. Here's what he learned, including the mistakes.

If AI is making your transactional work faster, this is where that speed turns into margin instead of a smaller bill. (Why that matters: AI Makes You Faster. The Billable Hour Makes That a Pay Cut.)

Put the price and the scope in writing

Jay's rule was simple: spell out the price, and spell out the scope of the work, so there's no misunderstanding later. His firm called these documents "scope and value statements." Ron Baker, the value-pricing author Jay credited for much of his thinking, calls them fixed price agreements.

Jay's statements were plain email, not formal contracts. He sent the scope and price, and if the client didn't push back, he took that as acceptance. Some clients would approve only the first phase or two and revisit later, and that was fine. He flagged one exception: when a fee has a contingency or success element, his state required a signed writing, and he said many states that follow the Model Rules do too. Check your own jurisdiction's rules on fee agreements.

And no legalese. Jay said they didn't use it "ever, ever, ever," and joked that you could get fired at his firm for writing "pursuant to."

Price in phases, not line items

Early on, Jay's firm priced litigation item by item: so much for answering interrogatories, so much for document requests, so much for a full-day deposition, so much for a half-day. He called that a mistake, for two reasons.

  • It invites nickel-and-diming. A list of small prices gives a budget-conscious client a dozen places to push back. One price for a phase is easier to accept.
  • It causes scope creep. With lots of small items, anything you forgot to list becomes an awkward question: charge extra, or eat it? Larger phases draw bigger boundaries and make you think about the whole job up front.

His firm settled on a few large phases per matter, such as discovery and summary judgment, and sometimes a single price for a matter they understood well. A will-and-trust engagement might be one price for the will and another for the trust.

Same matter, two ways to price it

Line itemsSo much per deposition, per interrogatoryA dozen places for the client to push backForgot an item? Charge extra, or eat it
PhasesOne price for discovery, one for summary judgmentOne price is easier to acceptBigger boundaries: the whole job, thought through up front
The instructor's firm started with line items, called that a mistake, and moved to a few large phases.

Use change orders, but carefully

Sometimes the job really changes. Jay's example: you're drafting a will, and partway through it becomes clear the client needs a special trust nobody anticipated. That's a new thing, and it's fair to price it. Contractors do this when they find an abandoned oil tank where the foundation goes. He compared it to upgrading to a double quarter pounder: you're buying more, so you pay more.

But he warned against letting change orders take over:

"You do not want them to be the tail that wags the dog. You do not want your client to think that it's a bait and switch."

His test: if you should have anticipated it, it's in the price. A discovery motion is common in litigation, so Jay didn't write a change order for one. Failing to build it in was his mistake, not the client's. When a judge denied his firm's TRO motion and then invited them to renew it after expedited discovery, the second hearing was covered by the TRO-phase price. They won it, and he didn't bill for it again.

The change-order test

Should you have anticipated it?
YesIt's in the priceA discovery motion in litigation
No, it's a new thingChange orderA special trust nobody anticipated
The test and both examples are from the course. Use change orders carefully, so they don't become "the tail that wags the dog."

Don't let the invoice turn back into a timesheet

Jay's firm kept no timesheets. Their system had no way to record time. They tracked the work so they could tell clients what was happening, and listed it on invoices. Jay admitted that this troubled him: an invoice listing all the work done can look like an hourly bill with the hours stripped out, as if you're justifying the fee. His goal was to replace it with regular status updates, because the client is paying for a solution, not for the work. If you build your own process, it's worth starting where he wanted to end up.

For more on fee agreements from the SPU archive, see The Best Damned Fee Agreement You Ever Wrote and Don't Nickel and Dime Your Clients. To set the price itself, see Jay Shepherd's 14 steps. Prospective clients often meet your scope and pricing on your website before they meet you, so make sure it matches how you actually work. SPU offers a free review of your firm's website.

Watch the full course

The full module on fixed-price agreements, plus lectures on shifting risk away from the client, fixing pricing mistakes and the ethics of fixed fees, are part of Fixing Your Fees, Fixing Your Practice in the SPU community. It's included with SPU membership.

THE WEEKLY SPU BRIEF

Get one practical lesson for your firm every week.

Free, from practicing lawyers. Every issue includes a lesson from the archive. Unsubscribe anytime.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
The SPU Team

The SPU Team writes and edits Solo Practice University's articles. Susan Cartier Liebel founded SPU in 2009 to teach lawyers the practical side of building a practice, the part law school leaves out, with courses taught by practicing lawyers. Today SPU is a community for solo and small-firm lawyers, with an AI Fluency program for firms putting AI to work. Nothing here is legal advice: check your own jurisdiction's rules.

About Solo Practice University →