AI Makes You Faster. The Billable Hour Makes That a Pay Cut.
- Hourly billing puts your financial interest against your client's, and it penalizes the expertise that makes you fast.
- Start with a pilot: pick certain types of matters, price them up front, and skip the secret timesheets.
- When AI drafts in minutes, hourly billing hands the time saved back to the client; a fixed price lets you keep it.
If AI drafts the first version of a contract in minutes and you bill by the hour, you just gave yourself a pay cut. That's the problem facing every lawyer using AI for transactional work right now, and it's why one of the oldest courses in the Solo Practice University archive is suddenly one of the most relevant.
In November 2026, Baker McKenzie began encouraging its lawyers to move to value-based pricing, charging for the value of the work instead of the hours spent. Its global chair, Sunny Mann, told The Wall Street Journal that "the hourly rate isn't the right metric," and that he expects it to be a trend across the legal industry (Legal Cheek). As the coverage notes, AI can now do work like due diligence, contract drafting and review more quickly, and that puts pressure on a model that charges by the hour.
None of this would have surprised Jay Shepherd. He taught Fixing Your Fees, Fixing Your Practice for SPU: six recorded lectures on trashing the billable hour and pricing legal work properly. At the time he ran Shepherd Law Group, a Boston employment firm that represented companies. He opened his first lecture with a line most firms still can't say: "We don't bill by the hour. We don't ever bill by the hour."
Here's what Jay taught, and why AI makes it more urgent.
The billable hour puts you on the wrong side of your client
Jay's biggest objection was never about lawyer income. It was about incentives. Every client who calls a lawyer has a problem they want solved quickly, well and economically. Bill by the hour, and the lawyer's financial interest runs the other way.
"It creates a conflict of interest between the lawyer and the client... People respond to incentives."
He was careful to say this isn't about padding bills. Very few lawyers do that. The problem is subtler: an hourly incentive pushes everyone to do more than good enough. He described an associate who finds the three or four cases that matter in an hour, versus a big-firm associate chasing an hours target who reads twenty cases and writes a memo nobody needed. Same answer. Very different bill.
AI widens that gap. When a tool can surface the leading cases or mark up a draft in minutes, the hourly model asks you to choose between your client's interest and your own revenue. Fixed pricing removes the choice.
Same work, two ways to bill it
Why should you be punished for being good?
Jay's second argument lands even harder now. Hourly billing penalizes expertise. He used his own non-compete practice as the example: years of similar cases meant he could reuse a prior brief, update the research and plug in new facts in hours, not days. Billing hourly, he couldn't capture any of the value of that experience.
"Why should I, the lawyer, why should you, be punished for being good at what you do?"
Swap "experience" for "a well-built AI workflow" and the argument is identical. The firm that invests in templates, prompts and review checklists gets faster, and the hourly model hands every minute saved back to the client as a discount nobody asked for. Price the outcome and the efficiency is yours.
Rates are not prices
On his whiteboard, Jay drew a distinction that clears up a lot of confused thinking about fees:
"Rates are not prices... If the lawyer doesn't know the price, the client doesn't know the price."
A rate tells a client almost nothing until you know how long the work will take, and most lawyers can't predict that. He told the story of a co-counsel call with a partner from a large firm. The partner billed the shared client about 50% more per hour than Jay did, then stopped the clock to ask Jay for advice on a different case, because Jay knew more about non-competes. The higher rate reflected the bigger firm's costs, not more value to the client. That call helped push Jay's firm to drop hourly billing at the end of 2006.
Rates are not prices
Small firms can turn faster than an aircraft carrier
Jay compared a big firm changing its billing model to turning an aircraft carrier: it's possible, but the sheer mass takes miles to change course. A solo or small firm can decide this week. He was blunt that waiting for clients to demand it is the wrong approach:
"It's not up to our clients to tell us how to create and construct a law firm business model. It's up to us."
Baker McKenzie is now turning its carrier. A solo with a few good AI workflows and a clear price list can be there already.
Where to start
Jay didn't recommend a gradual approach. He thought you can't do value pricing a little bit, and that firms keeping secret timesheets "to make sure we're not losing money" are missing the point. But he did suggest a pilot: pick certain types of matters, price them up front, and learn from it, which is exactly how his firm started.
For the mechanics, read our two companion pieces: how to set a fixed price, using Jay's 14 steps, and how to write the fixed-price agreement so the price holds up. For more from the SPU archive on this, see Price Should Be the Value to Your Client, Not Your Cost to Provide. Your pricing story also lives on your website, so check what yours says about how you charge. SPU offers a free law firm website review.
Watch the full course
The complete course, Fixing Your Fees, Fixing Your Practice, is in the SPU community: six lectures and about 6.8 hours of material, plus a hands-on exercise where you price one of your own services and get feedback from other members. It's included with SPU membership.
Get one practical lesson for your firm every week.
Free, from practicing lawyers. Every issue includes a lesson from the archive. Unsubscribe anytime.
The SPU Team writes and edits Solo Practice University's articles. Susan Cartier Liebel founded SPU in 2009 to teach lawyers the practical side of building a practice, the part law school leaves out, with courses taught by practicing lawyers. Today SPU is a community for solo and small-firm lawyers, with an AI Fluency program for firms putting AI to work. Nothing here is legal advice: check your own jurisdiction's rules.
About Solo Practice University →