Legal Ethics Questions for Solo and Small Firm Lawyers
LAST UPDATED
How Can You Ethically Share Legal Fees With a Lawyer Who Works Outside of Your Firm?

Alan practices family law in his firm. Grace primarily handles personal injury matters for her law firm. John Client calls Alan about a potential personal injury case. Alan smartly declines this representation since it is beyond his area of expertise. He refers John Client to Grace who later decides to represent John Client.
Grace tells Alan that she will pay him a referral fee such that Alan will receive a percentage of what she receives under the contingency fee agreement signed by John Client. Alan assumed joint responsibility for the representation but he did not provide any legal services to John Client. Grace does a great job on the case and later achieves a significant settlement amount for John Client. Alan asks Grace for his referral fee but Grace refuses to pay Alan. Alan decides to sue Grace to collect his referral fee.
Will Alan Recover His Referral Fee?
- Answer A: Yes, because Grace is in breach of their agreement.
- Answer B: No, Alan did not provide any legal services to John Client so he is not entitled to any legal fees.
- Answer C: Yes, but only if John Client agreed to the division of fees in writing.
Scroll down for the answer.
The correct answer is C This question is very loosely based on the case Naughton v. Pfaff, 2016 Ill. App. 2d. 150360 (May 10, 2016). In this case, the two attorneys had a long standing written referral fee agreement, but Pfaff refused to pay Naughton a referral fee in relation to one particular matter. Naughton filed a complaint against Pfaff for breach of fiduciary duty and to recover the referral fee. Pfaff moved for summary judgment arguing that the referral fee agreement for that particular matter was not enforceable because it did not comply with Rule 1.5(e) in that the client in that matter had not consented to the division of the fee in writing. The trial court granted the motion for summary judgment and the appellate court affirmed. While this is an instructive Illinois case about ethically sharing fees that is worth reading in its entirety, always check the ethics rules and opinions in your jurisdiction.
How did YOU do?
Can a Lawyer be Subject to Discipline for Not Understanding Technology?

Alan represents BL Company in a civil case against LA Company. LA Company is represented by Grace. Shortly after Grace filed an Answer to the Complaint, the court ordered the parties to meet and submit a joint discovery plan.
Alan brings a draft to the meeting prepared to discuss it with Grace. Grace reviews it and points out that Alan makes no reference to e-discovery in his proposed draft. Alan is a little surprised by this because he didn’t think e-discovery would be an issue in the case. Grace insists that it will be an issue and she adds provisions for e-discovery in Alan’s draft. Alan reviews it and signs off on the draft. The final joint discovery plan is submitted to the court, made into an order and entered by the court. Alan sends the order to BL Company and instructs BL Company to allow the firm’s vendor access to their network.
Did Alan breach any ethical duties?
- Answer A: No, Alan discussed the discovery plan with Grace; they came to an agreement about the plan; and he sent the order to the client so it could proceed with the process of identifying relevant documents.
- Answer B: Yes, Alan should have discussed the e-discovery issue with his client and talked to an IT expert before agreeing to the plan Grace proposed
Scroll down for the answer.
The correct answer is B. This question is very loosely based on California State Bar Formal Opinion No. 2015-193. This opinion highlights a lawyers ethical duty to understand technology and in this case e-discovery. In the opinion, the attorney did not understand e-discovery; and failed to consult with anyone to understand it. The danger is that the plan proposed by Grace could have been overly broad; oppressive; or unrealistic in the given time frame. Delegating the process to a vendor without some understanding or oversight can potentially lead to the disclosure of confidential and/or privileged documents. ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct Rule 1.1 Comment 8 says that for lawyers to be competent, he/she should keep abreast of current technology which includes its risks and benefits. At least 40 states, plus D.C. and Puerto Rico, have amended their ethic rules to impose a duty on lawyers to keep abreast of current technology. As always, you must check the ethics rules and opinions of your jurisdiction.
How did YOU do?
What Are the Ethical Concerns to Consider When Facing a Motion for Sanctions?

There are some litigation matters that are more contentious than others. The parties are angry at each other. You and your opposing counsel seem to be in a constant battle. If your opposing counsel files a Motion for Sanctions against you and your client what ethical concerns must you consider?
Grace represents Wife in a divorce case. Alan represents Husband. The case is very contentious as Wife and Husband hate each other and they have been fighting over custody and visitation in relation to their three children. When the Wife is awarded custody of the children, Alan files an appeal. Grace files a Motion for Sanctions against Alan and Husband claiming that the appeal is frivolous and intended to embarrass and harass the Wife; and to compel her to incur unnecessary attorney fees. In responding to the Motion, Alan argues that he filed the appeal in good faith, but if any sanctions are imposed, they should be imposed against his client who provided the facts that formed the basis of the appeal.
- Answer A: No, Alan filed an appeal in good faith based on information he received from his client. His client should bear the burden of the sanction alone.
- Answer B: Yes, by claiming that his client should bear the sanction, Alan created a conflict of interest with his client.
Scroll down for the answer.
The correct answer is B. This scenario is loosely based on the case In Re Marriage of Wixom and Wixom, 182 Wash. App. 881 (2014). In this case, the Court concluded that the advocacy of the attorney claiming that only his client should bear the sanction was directly adverse to his client’s interests in violation of Rule 1.7(a)(1). The Court stated that “central to the attorney’s duty of loyalty is not to devote time and effort to harm a client’s interest.” The Court held that an attorney may argue sanctions should only be imposed upon his client only through representation by independent counsel. While this is an instructive Washington case about the ethical issues that may arise when sanctions are claimed that is worth reading in its entirety, always check the ethics rules and opinions in your jurisdiction.
How did YOU do?
Can It Be Unethical to Help a Client?

In certain cases, you may have a client who is struggling financially while waiting for that hoped for recovery in the matter you are handling for them. You want to help them in some way, but can you? Consider the following scenario. The answer and explanation can be found at the bottom.
For about six months, Alan has been representing Charlie Client in a personal injury case where Charlie suffered damages such that he is unable to work. Charlie’s savings are almost exhausted as he tries to provide for his family. His rent is past due and his landlord is threatening to evict him if he doesn’t make payment right away. Charlie asks Alan to loan him $500 so he can pay his rent. Alan feels sorry for Charlie and his family and he wants to help him out.
Should Alan loan Charlie $500?
- Answer A: No. Lawyers are not supposed to loan money to clients.
- Answer B: Yes, of course he should. This situation would be considered an exception to the rule because Alan can’t sit by and let his client become homeless.
Scroll down for the answer.
The correct answer depends on the jurisdiction. ABA Model Rule 1.8(e) prohibits a lawyer from advancing payments to clients that are unrelated to the costs and expenses of litigation. Since 2020 the Model Rule has had a narrow exception for modest gifts to indigent clients represented pro bono, but it doesn’t cover loans or fee-paying clients. Outside that, most jurisdictions don’t recognize any exception to this general prohibition. For example, In re Smolen, 17 P.3d 456 (Okla. 2000)(no exception for “humanitarian” loan for disabled client’s living expenses). Also see, Grievance Commission of Maryland v. Kandel, 317 MD 274, 563 A.2d 387 (1989) (attorney reprimanded for advance payments to client for living expenses while personal injury case was pending). In contrast, In re Morse, 748 S.E. 2d 921(Georgia 2013) stated every instance of financial assistance does not always violate Rule 1.8(e); and Fla. Bar v. Taylor, 648 So. 2d 1190 (Fla. 1994) (no violation to give indigent client used clothing for child and $200 for necessities as “act of humanitarianism”). Before you consider engaging in any “acts of humanitarianism” make sure you check the ethics rules and opinions in your jurisdiction. This ethics question is for educational purposes only and is not intended to provide legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. When in doubt, seek ethics counsel in your jurisdiction.
How did YOU do?
Could The Use of Cloud-based Services Be an Ethical Violation?

We all know that the use of technology has transformed the delivery of legal services. Many case management systems are cloud based systems that change the way data is stored. But how does the use of cloud based systems affect a lawyer’s ethical obligations? Consider the following scenario. The answer and explanation can be found at the bottom.
Alan has just started to use an outside provider for cloud-based services so he can manage his law practice. He maintains all of his client data and client files through the cloud based service and it really helps him to be organized. He is excited that he has been able to eliminate paper files from his office. One day, Alan received a notice from his vendor advising him that their server has been compromised and all customer data, including all of Alan’s client data has been inadvertently disclosed.
Has Alan violated any of his ethical obligations?
- Answer A: Yes. Alan is ultimately responsible for the disclosures of confidential client information pursuant to Rule 1.6.
- Answer B: No. Alan cannot be held responsible for the acts of his cloud based service provider.
Scroll down for the answer.
The correct answer is it depends. Illinois Professional Conduct Advisory Opinion No. 16-06 (October 2016) states that the question to ask is whether the attorney acted reasonably and competently to protect the confidential information. Lawyers must conduct a due diligence investigation when selecting a provider. Reasonable inquires could include: (1) investigating whether the provider has implemented reasonable security precautions to protect client data from inadvertent disclosures; (2) investigating the provider’s reputation and history; (3) requiring an agreement to reasonably ensure that the provider will abide by the lawyer’s duties of confidentiality and will immediately notify the lawyer of any breaches or outside requests for client information; and (4) requiring that all data is appropriately backed up completely under the lawyer’s control so that the lawyer will have a method for retrieval of the data.
This opinion is consisted with other state bar associations. See e.g., Alabama Ethics Opinion 2010-2 (2010)(lawyer may outsource storage of client files through cloud computing if the lawyer takes reasonable steps to make sure data is protected); Iowa Ethics Opinion 11-01(2011)(lawyer should conduct appropriate due diligence before storing files electronically); Tennessee Formal Ethics Opinion 2015-F-159(2015)(a lawyer may allow client information to be stored in the cloud provided the lawyer takes reasonable care to assure that the information remains confidential and that reasonable safeguards are employed to protect information from breaches, loss or other risks).
This ethics question is for educational purposes only and is not intended to provide legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. When in doubt, seek ethics counsel in your jurisdiction.
How did YOU do?
Should Lawyers Be Disciplined for What They Say?

Unwanted touching in the work place is conduct that would not be appropriate. Such conduct has been the subject of attorney discipline. But, what about inappropriate communications? Should lawyers be disciplined for that they say? Consider the following scenario. The answer and explanation can be found at the bottom.
Attorney Denny and Attorney Angela are opposing counsel in a highly complex commercial litigation case. Discovery has been particularly nasty. Angela has filed multiple motions to compel discovery from Denny. The attorneys struggle to even agree on a date to depose witnesses. During one deposition, Denny asked for a document that Angela realized she left in her car. When she got up to retrieve it, Denny said, “Hurry up, Babe! We ain’t got all day!” When she returned to the room, she told Denny that she did not appreciate being called “Babe”. Denny smiled and said, “Be glad I didn’t call you a Bimbo.” The deposition proceeded while Angela fumed. When she returned to her office later that day, there was an email from Denny that said, “You whore b%$#%! Stop filing all these motions against me.”
Has Denny violated any of his ethical duties?
- Answer A: Yes. Denny is completely out of line and should be disciplined.
- Answer B: No. Denny has a right to free speech and Angela should ignore him and focus on representing her client.
Scroll down for the answer.
The correct answer depends on the jurisdiction. This scenario is very loosely based on a news story out of Illinois on January 19, 2017, where the attorney made inappropriate misogynist comments to his female opposing counsel. http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/ct-lawyer-suspended-sexist-remarks-met-20170119-story.html His comments were made known and the Federal Court suspended him from practicing before the Federal Court for one year. Another inspiration for this scenario is the case Mullaney v. Aude, 730 A. 2d 759 (Md. Ct. Spec. App. 1999), where the court rejects the attorney’s argument that his use of “Babe” in reference to his female opposing counsel was a term of endearment in honor of Babe Ruth. Many jurisdictions have some variety of anti-discrimination and anti-harassment provisions in the black letter of the rules. In Illinois, the rule can be found at 8.4(j). In August 2016, the ABA adopted an anti-sexual harassment and anti-discrimination rule and it can be found at Rule 8.4(g).
How did YOU do?
Lawyers and Other People’s Personal Information

The belief that “The odds of a computer or network breach isn’t an if, it’s only a when” is practically dogma now. Given this reality, every law practice, to include solo attorneys, should have a data security plan in place. Yes, I know the task can seem a bit daunting, particularly if you have no idea where to start; but failing to do this is no longer an acceptable choice. Putting our ethical duties and various state and federal regulations aside, every client expects to have whatever sensitive and personally identifying information they provide to you properly safeguarded. That’s the bottom-line.
The good news for lawyers who practice in the solo space is data security plans needn’t be drafted in the form of some long-convoluted treatise on IT security. It’s really more of a process followed up with a list of to-dos. If you happen to have any staff, you will also need to create a list of guidelines and expectations to be followed on a going forward basis.
The entire process can be summarized as follows. First, determine what sensitive and personally identifiable information you have and then identify all the locations where this information is stored. Second, determine if there is a legitimate reason to collect and maintain every piece of this information. If certain types of information aren’t really needed, stop collecting it. Third, figure out how to properly secure all information that must be kept and then take whatever steps are necessary to do so. Fourth, properly destroy any information that doesn’t need to be maintained. And finally, create an incident response plan so you know what to do if and when a breach occurs.
To help you move forward with this task, I encourage you to take a look at a useful guide put out by the Federal Trade Commission that is intended to help small businesses protect personal and sensitive information. This guide provides the details and instructions most small businesses need in order to make taking the above steps a palatable task. Finally, the FTC has also published a data breach response guide where additional information on what to do if and when you experience a breach can be found.
Could Your Law License Be Suspended For Not Having A Valid Email Adress?
In South Carolina, apparently so. Now for those of you reading this you are more than likely using your mobile device or tablet or desktop computer and this blog post was received via the internet to your email address. As a matter of fact, you probably can't even conceive of not having internet access. You are very likely in the majority of practitioners, too.
However, some Luddites still exist in the profession. Maybe more than we think.
The action stems from an order that was issued in October of 2011 that stated that all attorneys must include a “mailing address, an e-mail address, and a telephone or cell phone number” in their profile on South Carolina’s “Attorney Information System.” The legal wrangling in this particular case starts with this order and includes dozens of frivolous filings and months of ‘snail-mail’ correspondence. The short of it is that the attorney refused to get a valid e-mail address and the S.C. Supreme Court found that conduct sanctionable. The primary reason listed for the attorney’s refusal is that she “is retired ‘as there have been no clients in over thirty (30) years’ and she does not have Internet access.”
While I'm sure there was a little more to the suit which aggravated the commission, the upshot is the final bell has rung. This case clearly states the following:
...the Court found that the attorney and her conduct posed “a substantial threat of serious harm to the public and to the administration of justice” and she was suspended.
The bare bones of this lawsuit finally let's every lawyer know in unequivocal terms that technology is no longer discretionary but an absolute requirement if you are to honor your professional obligations. Don't be surprised when other technological advancements are also deemed basic essential tools for the proper practice of law such as e-discovery, electronic delivery of all filings to both the courts and opposing counsel, discovery and pleadings to opposing counsel, and more.
What Are The Ethics Surrounding Delegation of Legal Work - Guest Lecture with Cynthia Sharp

In order to grow, solos will need to delegate legal work to paralegals, administrative staff, free lance lawyers and associates and any vendor you hire on your behalf. Even hiring a marketing firm! But do you really know the ethics surrounding delegation of work you are ultimately ethically responsible for as the the owner of your law firm? This is a critically important topic. Listen and learn.
The audio is about 40 minutes. Listen directly below.
Veteran attorney Cynthia Sharp (CEO of The Sharper Lawyer) works with motivated lawyers seeking to generate additional revenue for their law firms. She practiced law from 1982 - 2009 and then embarked on a professional speaking and writing career. Ever since, she has served solo and small firm attorneys throughout North America.
Cindy, author of The Lawyer’s Guide to Financial Planning published by ABA Solo, Small Firm and General Practice Division, is also a Contributor to the Division’s books How to Capture and Keep Clients: Marketing Strategies for Lawyers as well as Effectively Staffing Your Law Firm.
She has delivered close to 200 live presentations over the past 25 years on behalf of the American Bar Association, 10 state bar associations, the Million Dollar Round Table, Professional Services Marketing Association and numerous other legal, financial and professional groups in addition to private seminars conducted for her clients.
Cindy served as Business Development columnist on behalf of the ABA GP Solo eReport, Social Media Strategist for GP Solo and has served as a regular guest contributor to ALM’s publication Marketing the Law Firm. In addition, she has written well over 120 articles over the past 30 years that have been published in various journals throughout the country.
During 2017/18, Cindy held positions on the GP Solo and eReport Boards of the ABA Solo, Small Firm & General Practice Division, having previously served as Chair of the Publications Board of the Division and on the Division’s Council. She completed her term as President of the Philadelphia Chapter of the National Speakers Association in June of 2015 and served as Dean of the Speaker Academy the subsequent year. Sharp has also been an active member in the Association of Continuing Legal Education (ACLEA). She has continued her service to her colleagues through a podcast featured on Solo Practice University.
Among Cindy’s accolades, she was named Trainer of the Year by the American Bar Association Solo, Small Firm and General Practice Division, a national award presented in New York City on May 3, 2019.
Cindy lives in Philadelphia with her husband, Mark H. Gallant and their dog Rocky and cat Jackson. She practices yoga, enjoys the arts and loves to bake.
Get one practical lesson for your firm every week.
Free, from practicing lawyers. Every issue includes a lesson from the archive. Unsubscribe anytime.
Allison Wood taught at Solo Practice University (2012).
Full profile and more posts →